Capital Markets
All
Beyond the Deal: How Relationships and Trust Create Value in M&A
By 
Debby Cordeiro, Managing Director, Capital Market Communications

Over the past 25 years, I’ve had the privilege of supporting more than 30 mergers and acquisitions across industries and organizations. While every transaction is unique, one lesson has remained constant: the role of communications extends far beyond the announcement. The most successful transactions are those where communication is treated as a strategic function before, during, and long after the deal closes.

Because M&A is about a transaction—but only for a moment in time.

The enduring value of an acquisition is built through something far less tangible: relationships and trust.

Timing matters. And context is content.

Too often, communicators are brought in when the deal is fully baked and the announcement is days away. By then, an important opportunity has already passed.

Communications has its own form of due diligence. Long before the first news release is drafted, communications teams can assess reputation, review the acquiree’s narrative infrastructure, identify potential issues, anticipate stakeholder reactions, and monitor, even influence, an external environment that shifts daily.

While corporate development teams, CFOs, investment bankers, and legal advisors focus on valuation, synergies, and transaction structure, communicators focus on context. And today, context is every bit as material as content.

Early involvement does not simply produce better messaging. It produces better-informed decisions.

There is one conversation I have come to expect in virtually every transaction I have worked on. I think of it as the predictable wildcard.

By then, the numbers have been negotiated and the legal documents are nearly complete.

Then someone—typically one CEO to the other—asks the question everyone knew was coming:

"So… what happens to the brand?"

I have seen that single question become a negotiating lever time and time again.

At first glance, it may seem like a simple question about naming, identity, or visual assets. It is anything but. It is a conversation about trust, relationships, customer loyalty, employee pride, community connections, and legacy. It is often the moment when leaders confront something that does not appear in a financial model: the emotional value of a business.

I have seen entire integration strategies shift because of this conversation alone.

The instinctive answer is often, “We’ll figure it out together.” But that is rarely enough. People need clarity. They need to understand what will be preserved, what will change, and why. They need promises they can believe you will deliver on.

A news release is not a summary of your contract. It’s your first contract with your stakeholders.

The announcement is the organization’s first public commitment following a strategic decision. Every stakeholder reads it through a different lens: employees, customers, investors, regulators, partners, and the media are all looking for signals about what comes next.

The temptation is to optimize the message for one audience over another. But the announcement is the one element every stakeholder group will scrutinize. It is where expectations are set and trust begins to form.

Trust remains one of the most valuable financial and extra-financial assets an organization has, and one of the easiest to lose.

Outside of the business echo chamber of deal-making, communicators are brokering trust insurance contracts.

The announcement is only the beginning.

I have been fortunate to witness some truly best-in-class integrations. I have also seen what happens when momentum fades after announcement day.

Yet this is precisely when communication matters most.

The narrative cannot stop when the transaction closes. Stakeholders do not experience an acquisition through integration plans; they experience it through consistent actions over time. Building a narrative that continues to align with the promises made on day one is the real litmus test of successful M&A communications.

The organizations that succeed over the long term understand this. They invest in retaining talent, co-creating culture, and maintaining a clear tone from the top. They recognize that trust is earned not through a single announcement but through the consistency between what they say and what they do.

After 25 years and more than 30 transactions, my belief remains simple:

Financial models can estimate synergies. Contracts can define ownership. Integration plans can map the work ahead.

But relationships and trust determine whether people choose to believe in the future you are asking them to build together.

In a nutshell, communications does not just bring perspective. It’s business leverage.

Related insights

Crisis & Reputation
All
The Importance of Scanning for Issue Signals
When outcomes depend on more than a single decision maker.
Signal Hill works with leaders across government, capital markets and institutions. When the forces shaping your most consequential decisions are still forming, we help you read the landscape and act before outcomes are set. Get in touch to discuss how we can help.